“Which is the most powerful van for you? Toyota and Nissan factions are having a huge debate on social networking sites! Insatiable battle between Hiace and Caravan!
Commercial Vans “”Hiace”” and “”Caravan”” What are the voices comparing both vehicles?
The Toyota Hiace, which underwent a partial makeover on April 13, 2022, and the Nissan Caravan, whose diesel version underwent a minor change in April of the same year.
Both vehicles represent commercial vans, and there are many voices comparing such two vehicles on SNS. What are the charms of each model?
Image] Similar or not? No similarity? Let’s compare the differences between the “”Hiace”” and the “”Caravan,”” which are strong rivals (23 photos).
(Top) Toyota Hiace / (Bottom) Nissan’s new Caravan
On April 13, 2022, Toyota announced a partially improved model of the Hiace (van, wagon, commuter).
The commercial van that is compared to the Hiace is the Nissan Caravan.
In October 2021, the Caravan also underwent minor changes, including design changes and functional improvements, with the gasoline-powered version leading the way. In April 2022, the diesel model also underwent minor changes.
On social networking sites, there are many comments comparing the two vehicles, such as “”If I had to choose between the Hiace and the Caravan, the Hiace is easier to drive”” and “”I prefer the Caravan to the Hiace.
So what are the differences between these two vehicles? In this article, we will compare both the Hiace (Van/Super GL/FWD/Standard width/Standard roof) and the Caravan (Van/Premium GX/FWD/Standard width/Standard roof) mainly in terms of luggage space and engine.
The body size of the Hiace (standard width/standard body) is 4695 mm (overall length) x 1695 mm (overall width) x 1980 mm (overall height).
The body size of the CARAVAN (standard width, standard body) is almost the same: 4695 mm (overall length) x 1695 mm (overall width) x 1990 mm (overall height).
Although these two vehicles are similar, is there any difference in luggage space, which is probably the most important point of concern for a commercial van?
The luggage space of the Hiace is 3000mm long (1855mm when rear seats are in normal position, 1975mm when rear seats are slid forward, and 2470mm when rear seats are folded) x 1320mm high x 1520mm wide.
The cargo area of the current Hiace, which was introduced in 2004, was developed with the aim of achieving the largest cargo area efficiency in its class at that time.
The engine-direct cooling fan was replaced with an electric fan. In addition, by placing the radiator in the front nose and bringing the engine position to the front to the utmost limit, one of the largest cargo floor lengths in the 1-ton cab van class (as of 2004) has been realized.
On the other hand, the luggage space of the current Caravan (the “”NV350 Caravan”” at the time of its debut), which was introduced in 2012, is 3050 mm (cargo space length) x 1325 mm (cargo space height) x 1520 mm (cargo space width).
Despite the fact that the body size itself is almost the same for both vehicles, the later Caravan has further trimmed down the space to further increase the luggage space.
The Caravan’s luggage space is expanded through a seat arrangement in which the second-row seats are folded forward, which increases the cargo capacity by approximately 250 kg. Nissan explains that the length of the cargo space can also be used to load a long stepladder.
Even with the second-row seats up and the vehicle’s five-person capacity, two mountain bikes and other large leisure equipment, such as snowboards and boots, can be loaded.
In the higher grade Caravan, the second row seats can be split independently to the left and right, a feat not possible with the Hiace, which has integrated second row seats on both sides. As mentioned above, in terms of cargo height and cargo space length, the Caravan is only slightly higher than the Hiace in terms of numerical values.
However, in terms of actual cargo access and efficiency, the Hiace, with its large-opening back doors, seems to be unbeatable.
On social networking sites, there are various comments depending on the way of loading and the user’s purpose, such as “”Caravan has wider cargo space than Hiace,”” “”Caravan has wider cargo space and is more convenient,”” “”Hiace has wider cargo space when the rear is not folded down,”” and “”Hiace can make effective use of space in the end. The following are some of the comments received.
Which is the strongest van for you? Toyota and Nissan factions are having
What are the differences in engine performance between the Hiace and the Caravan?
Let us now compare the engine performance of the two vehicles.
Many people on SNS are comparing the two vehicles based on engine performance, saying, “”The Mitsubishi engine in the new Caravan looks more comfortable than the Hiace’s,”” and “”I wonder if the Hiace’s engine performance is better…
The Toyota Hiace’s engine lineup consists of the 2-liter “”1TR-FE”” and 2.7-liter “”2TR-FE”” gasoline models and the 2.8-liter “”1GT-FTV”” diesel turbo diesel model.
Maximum output is 136ps for the gasoline 1TR-FE, 160ps for the 2TR-FE, and 151ps for the diesel 1GT-FTV; maximum torque is 182Nm for the gasoline 1TR-FE, 243Nm for the 2TR-FE, and 300Nm for the diesel 1GT-FTV.
The gasoline engine is equipped with Dual VVT-i (continuously variable valve timing system for intake and exhaust) to achieve both high output and low fuel consumption.
In addition, the diesel engine’s fuel efficiency was improved in April 2022 with partial improvements, and together with the “”achievement of the 2015 fuel efficiency standard plus 15%,”” it is eligible for the eco-car tax reduction program.
In contrast, Nissan’s new Caravan has three types of engines: 2-liter “”QR20DE”” and 2.5-liter “”QR25DE”” gasoline models, and 2.5-liter “”4N16″” diesel turbo diesel model.
Maximum output is 130ps for the gasoline QR20DE, 147ps for the QR25DE, and 132ps for the diesel 4N16; maximum torque is 178Nm for the gasoline QR20DE, 213Nm for the QR25DE, and 370Nm for the diesel 4N16.
The Caravan’s gasoline engine is an inline 4-cylinder that accelerates powerfully even when heavily loaded, and its quietness is achieved through the use of a balancer shaft that suppresses the engine’s unpleasant humming noise at high speeds.
The performance of the gasoline engine, however, is slightly higher than that of the Hiace in terms of both output and fuel economy.
On the other hand, the new diesel engine loaded in the new Caravan offers smoother acceleration performance and quieter operation.
The catalog fuel consumption is 11.3km/L (WLTC mode), which is the same as the diesel engine of the Hiace, but the maximum torque of the Caravan is higher than that of the Hiace, and the Caravan with its torque may be the perfect choice for transporting heavy loads.
* * *
The Toyota Hiace and Nissan Caravan are compared as the same commercial van, but each has many unique attractions.
Vehicle prices (including consumption tax) for the Hiace range from 2,192,000 yen to 4,118,000 yen for the van, 2,886,000 yen to 3,994,000 yen for the wagon, and 3,221,000 yen to 3,747,000 yen for the commuter.
The Caravan ranges from 2,412,300 yen to 4,275,700 yen for the van, 3,095,400 yen to 4,097,500 yen for the wagon, and 375,300 yen for the microbus.
Each of these improved models has just been released. Comparison by price as well as design and performance will be one of the deciding factors in the purchase.”